2008 Woodie Awards
Paranormal romance proves disappointing
Susan Page
Issue date: 4/12/07 Section: Entertainment
- Page 1 of 2 next >
Browsing through the romance section at a local book store, I spotted an author I'd never seen before. Curious, I picked it up and quickly read the blurb on the back. The book's premise was interesting enough to make me want to give it a chance. But this novel by Allie MacKay - who also writes medieval romances under the name Sue-Ellen Welfonder - starts out promising but flounders with each successive page.
All romance novels must fulfill two criteria: The story must focus on the romantic relationship between two people and it must have a happy ending.
Even paranormal romance novels - stories that have otherworldly traits like ghosts, time travel or magic - have to obey these rules.
And even after they meet these requirements, it still doesn't guarantee it will be good. "Highlander in Her Bed" is one of those books that doesn't leave a reader satisfied. Even when Mara cried, "Don't stop," I wished it would.
In present day London, Mara McDougall, a self-employed tour guide from Philadelphia, needs a breather from the ghost tour group she's been leading around the city. Slipping into an antique store, Mara spots a beautiful medieval, four-poster bed which she buys.
What she doesn't know is that her new bed is haunted by the ghost of Sir Alexander Douglas - a Scottish knight who was murdered by Mara's ancestor, Colin MacDougall, 700 years ago.
He has vowed that no one from her family will have a peaceful night in his bed. But when Alex and Mara meet it's lust at first sight.
MacKay can write well, but seems to slip into gimmicky phrases. The most abundant being "Hottie Scottie" which, at one point, appears four times on a single page. Alex is Scottish and he's very handsome. We get it.
The major flaw is the novel's utter lack of romance. The lead characters are too preoccupied with physical lust to really learn anything about one another other than basic personality traits. The chemistry between Alex and Mara boils down to nothing more than "Hey you're hot, let's do it." Their love is unrealistic because it doesn't seem rooted in anything but infatuation.
All romance novels must fulfill two criteria: The story must focus on the romantic relationship between two people and it must have a happy ending.
Even paranormal romance novels - stories that have otherworldly traits like ghosts, time travel or magic - have to obey these rules.
And even after they meet these requirements, it still doesn't guarantee it will be good. "Highlander in Her Bed" is one of those books that doesn't leave a reader satisfied. Even when Mara cried, "Don't stop," I wished it would.
In present day London, Mara McDougall, a self-employed tour guide from Philadelphia, needs a breather from the ghost tour group she's been leading around the city. Slipping into an antique store, Mara spots a beautiful medieval, four-poster bed which she buys.
What she doesn't know is that her new bed is haunted by the ghost of Sir Alexander Douglas - a Scottish knight who was murdered by Mara's ancestor, Colin MacDougall, 700 years ago.
He has vowed that no one from her family will have a peaceful night in his bed. But when Alex and Mara meet it's lust at first sight.
MacKay can write well, but seems to slip into gimmicky phrases. The most abundant being "Hottie Scottie" which, at one point, appears four times on a single page. Alex is Scottish and he's very handsome. We get it.
The major flaw is the novel's utter lack of romance. The lead characters are too preoccupied with physical lust to really learn anything about one another other than basic personality traits. The chemistry between Alex and Mara boils down to nothing more than "Hey you're hot, let's do it." Their love is unrealistic because it doesn't seem rooted in anything but infatuation.
Be the first to comment on this story