2008 Woodie Awards
Pageants don't reflect society
Megan Keller
Issue date: 4/12/07 Section: Opinion
It happens every year: Women parade down a catwalk in a variety of outfits to schmaltzy music. Within hearing the first few notes of the theme, you know exactly what you're watching: the annual Miss America and Miss USA pageants. While it's been debated for years that pageants are archaic and sexist, there is a greater issue at hand. The contestants are not relevant as models for youth today.
The pageants are supposed to exemplify female purity and success, but in this era, women no longer fit the molds. Miss America began as a lark to prolong the tourist season in Atlantic City. Miss USA started similarly as a "bathing beauty" competition, according to their Web site. Somehow, they parlayed themselves into Americana. Women have changed in many ways since the competitions began and the pageants need to reflect that.
The 2006 Miss USA, Tara Conner, nearly lost her crown after reports surfaced that she tested positive for cocaine and underage drinking amid other things. She entered rehab and was given a second chance by a true paragon of virtue, pageant owner Donald Trump. However, Trump was not so quick to forgive Katie Rees, Miss Nevada USA 2006, when racy photos of her surfaced on the Internet.
While these actions can be forgivable, should the youth of America be looking to them as a moral compass, especially young women? Obviously, two bad apples shouldn't spoil the bunch, but moral standards are looser than they used to be. Their behavior shouldn't be justified, yet can they really be expected to reign with responsibility and decorum?
Most women in their twenties go to clubs-even some who are underage. A 2005 study by the Monitoring the Future project at the University of Michigan found that three out of four students drank alcohol by the end of high school. Many college students "experiment"-its part of the learning process. Experimenting usually involves trying drugs, alcohol and things one wouldn't normally try. The college years are ones that should be spent discovering what kind of person you are. It's a time when most people don't consider how their actions affect others. The standards the pageants are based upon should be changed to reflect the societal changes that have occurred over the years.
The pageants are supposed to exemplify female purity and success, but in this era, women no longer fit the molds. Miss America began as a lark to prolong the tourist season in Atlantic City. Miss USA started similarly as a "bathing beauty" competition, according to their Web site. Somehow, they parlayed themselves into Americana. Women have changed in many ways since the competitions began and the pageants need to reflect that.
The 2006 Miss USA, Tara Conner, nearly lost her crown after reports surfaced that she tested positive for cocaine and underage drinking amid other things. She entered rehab and was given a second chance by a true paragon of virtue, pageant owner Donald Trump. However, Trump was not so quick to forgive Katie Rees, Miss Nevada USA 2006, when racy photos of her surfaced on the Internet.
While these actions can be forgivable, should the youth of America be looking to them as a moral compass, especially young women? Obviously, two bad apples shouldn't spoil the bunch, but moral standards are looser than they used to be. Their behavior shouldn't be justified, yet can they really be expected to reign with responsibility and decorum?
Most women in their twenties go to clubs-even some who are underage. A 2005 study by the Monitoring the Future project at the University of Michigan found that three out of four students drank alcohol by the end of high school. Many college students "experiment"-its part of the learning process. Experimenting usually involves trying drugs, alcohol and things one wouldn't normally try. The college years are ones that should be spent discovering what kind of person you are. It's a time when most people don't consider how their actions affect others. The standards the pageants are based upon should be changed to reflect the societal changes that have occurred over the years.
Viewing Comments 1 - 1 of 1
Terrence s. Kiolbassa
posted 4/13/07 @ 9:12 PM EST
I am not really a fan of beauty pangents, but some people want to watch them. Some people watch people hit little white balls and chase them. What can one say?
The thing I would like to see is people purchasing college and university coats for the daughters of legal Mexican immigrants. (Continued…)
Post a Comment